You’re looking at three VPNs. All three claim to be the best. All three have millions of users. And all three will happily take your money.

So which one do you actually pick?

I went through Reddit debates, forum arguments, and user reports to find out where each one genuinely wins and loses. Not the marketing claims. What real users are saying after a year of paying for these things.

My conclusion: There’s no single winner. But there’s a right pick for you — and it depends on exactly two things: your ISP and what you’re using it for.

See the current deals →

Short on Time? Here Are My Key Findings

One-sentence decision:

• Want the best balance of speed and features? → NordVPN.
• Don’t care about price, just want the most reliable? → ExpressVPN.
• On a budget or need unlimited devices? → Surfshark.

Speed — ExpressVPN Is the Fastest, but Nobody Actually Notices

Data summary: ExpressVPN averages ~400 Mbps on gigabit fiber via Lightway. NordVPN averages ~380 Mbps via NordLynx. Surfshark averages ~350 Mbps via WireGuard. All three handle 4K streaming without buffering.

Here are the numbers from AnandTech and Hacker News discussions:

ExpressVPN wins on raw speed. But here’s the thing: is ExpressVPN noticeably faster? I went through Hacker News and Reddit threads and the consensus is clear:

“Speed difference between NordVPN and ExpressVPN is negligible for 99% of users.” — Hacker News user

Unless you’re downloading massive files daily or running a server, you won’t feel the difference between 380 Mbps and 400 Mbps. Both buffer-free for 4K. Both fine for gaming.

Surfshark is slightly behind — but still fast enough for everything most people do.

Bottom line: ExpressVPN wins on paper. In practice, all three are fast enough for anything normal.

Features — NordVPN Has the Most, Surfshark Has the Best Value

Data summary: NordVPN offers 9,323+ servers in 111 countries, Threat Protection Pro, NordPass, Meshnet. Surfshark offers unlimited devices, CleanWeb, GPS spoofing. ExpressVPN keeps it simple with solid features and no upsells.

This is where the three diverge significantly.

NordVPN packs the most features: a password manager (NordPass), a malware blocker (Threat Protection Pro), a file-sharing tool (Meshnet), and encrypted cloud storage on Complete. But here’s the catch — you pay for these whether you use them or not.

“Don’t buy Complete if you already use Google Drive. You’re paying for features you’ll never open.” — RedFlagDeals Canada user

ExpressVPN takes the opposite approach. Fewer features, but everything it offers works flawlessly. Lightway protocol, Network Lock kill switch, and split tunneling. No bloatware. No upsells. Just a VPN that works.

Surfshark wins on value. Unlimited devices means a family of 5 can share one account. GPS spoofing is a genuine differentiator for mobile users. And it’s the cheapest of the three.

Bottom line: NordVPN for features, Surfshark for value, ExpressVPN for simplicity. Pick your poison.

Streaming — ExpressVPN Edges Ahead, but NordVPN Is Close

Data summary: ExpressVPN reliably unblocks Netflix US, BBC iPlayer, Disney+, and Amazon Prime. NordVPN matches on most platforms but occasionally struggles with BBC iPlayer. Surfshark works with Netflix and Disney+ but has more variable results.

ExpressVPN has a reputation for being the most reliable streaming VPN. Reddit users consistently confirm this — it just works with everything. AVForums members particularly praise it for BBC iPlayer:

“ExpressVPN works with BBC iPlayer 10/10 times. NordVPN is more like 7/10 — you might need to switch servers.” — AVForums user

That said, NordVPN’s streaming servers have improved significantly in 2026. HardwareZone SG users report reliable Netflix US access. Whirlpool Australia users confirm Stan and Amazon Prime AU work well.

Surfshark is fine for Netflix but some users report needing to clear browser cache or switch between WireGuard and OpenVPN to get streaming working on certain platforms.

Winner: ExpressVPN (most consistent. But NordVPN is close enough that most users won’t notice the difference.)

Pricing — Surfshark Is Cheapest, but Is Cheap Better?

Data summary: Surfshark Starter $2.19/mo. NordVPN Basic $3.09/mo. ExpressVPN Basic $4.99/mo. All three have 30-day money-back guarantees.

Surfshark is clearly the cheapest. But MoneySavingExpert UK users warn about a pattern: entry-level Surfshark lacks advanced features that NordVPN Basic includes. You get what you pay for.

“Surfshark Starter is fine. But NordVPN Basic at $0.90/mo more gives you Threat Protection and better servers.” — MoneySavingExpert UK user

Bottom line: Surfshark wins on price. NordVPN wins on value per dollar. ExpressVPN is premium pricing for a premium experience.

Privacy and Security — All Three Are Trustworthy

Data summary: All three have passed independent audits. NordVPN has 6 consecutive no-logs audits. ExpressVPN has TrustedServer (RAM-only) technology. Surfshark underwent a Cure53 audit in 2025.

If your primary concern is privacy, any of these three will keep you safe. The differences are marginal:

• NordVPN: 6 consecutive Deloitte audits. RAM-only servers. No confirmed data breach ever.
• ExpressVPN: RAM-only TrustedServer technology. Lightway protocol independently audited.
• Surfshark: Cure53 audited. RAM-only servers. Independent no-logs certification.

“NordVPN just passed its 6th no-logs audit. That’s a track record most competitors can’t match.” — Hacker News user

Winner — draw: All three pass. Pick the one whose feature set and price match your needs. Privacy is not a differentiator here.

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?

Score: No single winner — pick by your needs

Pick NordVPN if: You want the best feature-to-price ratio. Nine thousand+ servers means less congestion. NordLynx is fast enough for everything. Plus plan includes a password manager and malware blocker.

Pick ExpressVPN if: You value reliability over everything else. If you just want a VPN that works without any fuss and you’re willing to pay a premium for it, ExpressVPN is your pick.

Pick Surfshark if: You’re on a budget or need unlimited devices for a family. The cheapest option that still delivers solid performance. Just don’t expect the same server density or streaming consistency.

Check NordVPN plans → | ExpressVPN → | Surfshark →

FAQs

Is NordVPN faster than ExpressVPN?

No. ExpressVPN is about 5% faster on average. But you won’t notice the difference in daily use.

Which VPN is best for Netflix?

ExpressVPN is the most reliable. NordVPN works well too. Surfshark sometimes needs troubleshooting.

Which is the cheapest?

Surfshark at $2.19/mo. NordVPN at $3.09/mo. ExpressVPN at $4.99/mo.

Can I use these on multiple devices?

NordVPN: 10 devices. ExpressVPN: 8 devices. Surfshark: unlimited devices.

Which has the best refund policy?

All three offer 30-day money-back guarantees. No questions asked.